One factor that could lead to a pilot
shortage is new regulations that are set in place. First one being the age for
required retirement for pilots is 65 years old, this was recently changed a few
years ago that once stood at 60 years of age to retirement. There are a large
number of pilots that are currently within the 60-65 year range that take up
most of the higher seats at major airlines. In theory with is going to create a
large void on the top end of the major airlines. Major airlines will look to fill
there voids by looking into the regional airlines for their large number of
available pilots that are looking to move to the major carriers. There are very
few pilots that wish to make a lifelong career in the regional airlines. Regionals
are more of a stepping stone a way to build time and pad their log books.
Throughout this last decade the regionals have grown a considerable amount.
Financially major airlines can provide a better salary for the pilots and with
time can become a very lucrative option. With pay better the life style
improves, it is where many pilots wish to be at some point of their careers
becoming a captain for a major airline and move as high as they can on the
seniority list. Second reason is the new regulation 14 CFR 61.160 that has
recently been established. The new regulation requires either a 1000 hours
total time or 1500 hours total time depending on your training with an ATP to
be considered for a 121 operation; Whereas before the only requirement was
Commercial certificate and 250 hours total time. This new regulation can have
had effect on current and future aspiring pilots. Pilots in training now with
have to continue their entry level jobs until obtaining the required fight
time. Whereas future aspiring pilots may now feel less inspired to make a
career with piloting and may only consider piloting as a hobby or something
they will work for later on in life. For college route tuition and training
bills in excess of $100,000 on average, this is just the beginning, even after
completing your training you will still need at least 700 - 800 more hours
before one can interview for an airline (Goyer, 2011). This could cause a
stagnate point at the entry level piloting jobs such as flight instructing,
with instructors more reluctant to move on to other jobs. Stated in a NTSB
study Glenn Pew from avweb explains that the figures are 'predicted as the
result of both retirements and industry growth. Participants also told the NTSB
that fewer military pilots would be leaving their positions for jobs with the
airlines and, because they see it as an economic cul-de-sac, careers in
aviation are attracting fewer college students' (Pew, 2013).
If
there was a pilot shortage there could be multiple ramifications that are a
result. One concern that has been noted is the amount of pilots that have to
meet requirements. With required minimums higher, the cost of training rising,
and the poor pay at an entry level, the appeal to one considering a career in
aviation does not look as promising or as joyous as it may have once been. One
ramification that comes to mind first that could have a positive effect is
companies instilling a development program or special incentive program that is
appealing to possible prospects. There are other airlines in foreign countries
that have already had this in place and should be considered by airlines within
the United States to remain competitive. There has been a rapid growth in the
aviation industry in other developing countries and they are using ways to
persuade U.S. trained pilots to join their companies, not only providing them
with much assistance to get established in the new country but offering them a
considerable amount of money to fly for them. A development program could be
used in multiple different ways. One could be an agreement that if the airline
pays or trains a prospective pilot from the beginning until they meet minimum
requirements and ensures the have a job with the company once they are done,
with the pilot agreeing to a contract for the services for a agreed amount of
time. Another option could be a loan service by the airlines that give the
students a loan at an lower interest rates than banks or agreeing to start
paying for your training once you have reached a certain point in their
training. An incentive program could be an award system that could start as
early as the training process. When achieving the next highest level of
certificate the company could send a reward or have a signing bounce if a pilot
is hired by them. It does not have to always be money there can be other ways
to indulge pilots for someone in training it could be as simple as providing
the necessary reading and training material, or something that could be
rewarding in another area like a short weekend vacation or flight benefits.
There are endless things to use as a reward for the pilots to help keep them
motivated throughout and after training. Another ramification that could be
caused by a pilot shortage is higher wages for entry level jobs or a quicker
way to achieve a higher pay rate. Right now an entry level job in the airlines
is anywhere from $10,000 - $22,000 a year. With the pay only slowly increasing
until they have reached a captains status for a major airline, achieving
captain status can take many years. If the made the entry wages higher this can
improve the chances of luring in more pilots. This can be a positive and a
negative for aviation. Higher wages for pilots will improve morale for entry
level jobs and shine a better light for the airlines. With lower income it is a
turn off for many prospective pilots that are looking for a career in the
airlines. On the other hand, higher wages will make for a more competitive
market as well as more competitive pilots seeking these jobs. The negative
could cause for a smaller amount of pilots because the companies cannot afford
the higher pay of the pilots and still maintain a larger fleet. It could
possibly be as simple as better managing of the company.
There
has been many times in the past that a pilot shortage was a possibility or
something that is about to happen. Being an industry that is regulated this is
one of the few occupations that rely on your health and age. Aviation is like
any other market there are ups and downs, there are years that turnout very well
and years that look like it is the end of an industry. These ups and downs are
just cycles that everything must go through, what sustains is the ability to
adjust to times that may not have a glamorous outcome. There are many reasons
and many factors that play a role in a potential pilot shortage; On the other
hand this could be another situation that is over-exaggerated by the media.
There are many things today that the media proclaims that society clings onto
because of how possible it may seem or how realistic they seem. Many pilots
that I have personally spoken to all stated the something; they've said it
before and we managed, were still flying for these companies, like stated above
a possibility that there will be considerable amount of pilots retiring within
the next few years which could leave a sizable gap. However, it is not going to
happen overnight and the airlines are fully aware of statuses of their own
employees. Many news outlets react to the possibility as if it is happening all
at once or without warning. Major and Regional airlines are expecting changes
and will take the necessary steps to ensure the transition is as seamless as
possible. Major airlines will be looking to the regionals to help fill the need
of pilots; this will mean more of a loss for the regional airlines than the
majors. With the new additions to the major airlines this will affect the
regionals and will need to be looking for new options to now fill their own
seats. Many of the reports that is published by the media are simply looking at
an estimated loss not looking at the available pilots or pilots to be.
Brant Harrison are regional pilot suggests that "following massive
furloughs and restructuring at the airlines, the landscape is more of a basic
economic curve that 'is finally getting back to where the supply is matching
the demand.' They are expecting an airline growth of 1.4 percent a year (at
best) based on the amount of new aircraft ordered, however reports are not
taking into considerations of older aircraft that will need to be replaced
(Pew, 2013). Yes the amount of private
pilots has decreased 17% since the early 2000s however the amount of
certificate commercial pilots have remained steady with only minor fluctuation.
"This strikes me as a cynical effort on the part of some in the industry
to cry wolf and use scare tactics in an intent to influence the (FAA) when they
write the final rule on pilot experience to weaken it," CBS News aviation
and safety expert Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger (Kennedy,
2012). What this may mean is nothing less than a hiring cycle for many aviation
companies because it starts with the major airlines it will affect everything
that is below. Much like other industry there are years that require more
movement than what has be normal for the years leading up to this point. The
number of needed pilots may be higher than what we have become accustom to from
recent memory.
References
Goyer, Robert. (2011, November 07).
"Why the Coming Pilot Shortage Isn't Creating Lots of New Pilots . . .
Yet. Flying Magazine.Web. Retrieved September 22, 2013. <http:/www.flyingmag.com/blogs/going-direct/why-coming-pilot-shortage-isnt-creating-lots-new-pilots-yet>
Kennedy , Bruce. (2012, November 12).
Is the airline pilot shortage real?- MSN Money. Web. Retrieved September 22,
2013, from http://money.msn.com/top-stocks/post.aspx?post=941dc807-bfe1-4e9f-9410-07c3787ef094
Pew , Glen. (2013, May 23). The Pilot
Shortage Crisis Is Nigh! …
Or Not - AVweb Features Article. Retrieved September 22, 2013, from
http://www.avweb.com/news/features/pilot_shortage_crisis_forecasts_208746-1.html
Lee, Marc C. (2011, March 22). Pilot
Outlook 2010-2029: A Shortage Looms | PlaneAndPilotMag.com. Retrieved September
22, 2013, from
http://www.planeandpilotmag.com/proficiency/careers/pilot-outlook-2010-2029-a-shortage-looms.html
Good post Steve, you put a lot of information into this one. After reading through it, I found some of the same references I used in my post. Especially the part about the aviation market being cyclical, and now experiencing more of an upturn rather than a shortage. I feel like with newer regulations in training and required hours, there will start to be more involvement in the flight training and certification process in our country. I think the older model of relying on pilots to either come from the military or trained at small untowered airports is over and will transition to a University Degree system.
ReplyDeleteFAR 16.160 appear to be the last straw that will effectively ensure a pilot shortage in the near months. The major airliners will have quite a large number their pilots retiring (because of the international mandatory 65 years pilot retiring age) appear to be covered because they will harvest pilots from the regionals at virtually no change to their salary offers. The regionals, thanks in part to the 1500 rule will have to get very creative in their hiring process in order to maintain profit margins, satisfy new pilots and attract and maintain pilot interest in the profession.
ReplyDeleteI see that you mentioned the fact that the 65 year old pilots will be retiring which will give way to younger pilots seeking their positions. I believe this is overplayed a little too much. Yes, they changed the required retirement age 5 years ago from the age 60 to 65, but honestly, how many old guys are there at an airline? I know, there are a lot, but think of how much this has been put to a contributing factor to the pilot shortage. Are there really thousands of 64 year old airline captains out there? Maybe, I cant seem to find a number but I doubt it. I believe these retirees are just a drop in a much larger bucket. I think that the demand for more pilots greatly outweighs the fact that we have a lot of old guys flying 747s. The Asian market is booming and they don't have enough pilots to fill seats so they will be looking to American pilots to meet their demands. As American pilots are being swayed by very generous salaries at Asian airlines, American carriers will be struggling to find qualified pilots.
ReplyDelete